7th
Environmental Chemistry Student Symposium Judging Form
Oral
Presentation
Name:
Status:
Session:
Note to Judges: All
scores are out of 10 points except the Presentation category, which is out of
20. You do not need to add up the
scores at the end as the committee can do that later.
|
Category |
Score |
|
Background -
Information
clear and concise? -
Significance
stated? (Big picture) |
/
10 |
|
Problem and Hypothesis -
Research
question and hypothesis stated clearly? -
Novel
problem and/or approach? |
/ 10 |
|
Methods -
Methods concisely explained? -
Explanation
appropriate for interdisciplinary audience? (Acronyms defined, etc.) |
/ 10 |
|
Results -
Data
relevant to the research question? -
Data
clearly presented in tables and/or graphs? -
Data
interpreted for the audience? |
/
10 |
|
Discussion and Conclusions -
Relevance
of the data clearly explained? -
Conclusions
reasonable based on the data? -
Scientific
importance explained? -
Further
research suggested? |
/
10 |
|
Presentation -
Organized,
easy to follow, not rushed? -
Fonts
large enough? -
Text
short? not too many slides? -
Easy to
follow data, not a data overload? -
Technical
level appropriate for interdisciplinary audience? |
/
20 |
|
Presentation Overtime Penalty -
Subtract
10 points if more than 30 seconds over time limit |
|
|
Grand Total |
/
70 |
Further
Comments?